But...he's Casey! How could he get kicked off (again)? Ok, so I didn't vote so I can't REALLY gripe but he sure was enjoyable to watch. At the beginning of the season I thought it would be between Casey and Paul, then Paul was gone and I was left wondering about my original prediction :)  I am saddened that he is gone but I'm sure his signature is already dry on a recording contract (just like Pia). My new predictions? I think James has a real chance at winning but I'm not sure if he will be against Scotty or Lauren.  What do you think? Who will be our next Aaaaaaamerican Idol?